Budget cuts, a looming decommission, and an uncertain future for one of 51’s most beloved firefighters

The Fall Finale Cliffhanger That Started It All

Chicago Fire wrapped its fall finale with two explosive twists—but one might be more heartbreaking than life-threatening. While Severide and Van Meter were left trapped in a burning apartment, fans are more concerned about what the second twist could mean for the future of Firehouse 51.

Chief Pascal was informed that CFD leadership is reviewing rigs for permanent decommissioning. One of the first names on that list? Engine Company 51. And the fallout may land directly on Lieutenant Randall “Mouch” McHolland.

Is Mouch on the Chopping Block?

Budget cuts have hit the CFD hard—but so far, Firehouse 51 has mostly escaped layoffs. Hours have been trimmed, resources reallocated, and leadership stretched thin. Still, no firefighter has been officially reassigned or let go… yet.

Now, that could change.

The Mayor’s Chief of Staff made it clear: Engine 51 is at risk, and with it, Mouch’s current position. If the rig is decommissioned, the long-serving firefighter may be forced to leave the house he’s called home for years.

Leaving 51—But Not the Show?

The good news? A possible departure from 51 doesn’t have to mean a full exit from Chicago Fire. The writers could move Mouch to another station, allowing him to keep his rank while exploring new dynamics elsewhere in the CFD.

This direction would open up fresh storylines—Mouch adjusting to new coworkers, navigating leadership away from his support system, and proving himself all over again. It would also allow the show to explore the personal impact of budget cuts in a realistic, character-driven way.

Importantly, it would protect the growth Mouch achieved in Season 13, when he fought hard to earn his lieutenant title. A demotion just to keep him at 51 would feel like a step backward—and that’s something fans are hoping to avoid.

Hope for a Last-Minute Save?

Of course, Chicago Fire is known for last-minute turnarounds. Could Chief Pascal or Boden pull off a miracle to save Engine 51 from being decommissioned? It’s not impossible. But fans are bracing for the worst—and preparing to say goodbye to Mouch at Firehouse 51, even if not from the show entirely.